Remembering Patrick and Kelly Boughter ❤️ 6.27.2006

These are the sweet faces of the Boughter family: Yvonne and Patrick and their daughters Kelly and Morgan. On this weekend 14 years ago, they checked into a hotel in Ocean City, Maryland. After spending a day enjoying rides on the Boardwalk, they were looking forward to relaxing in their room and watching a movie together…a fun start to what was to be a week-long vacation. But within just a few hours, the four of them would be incapacitated in their hotel room, unable to escape the effects of an undetected toxic carbon monoxide (CO) leak.

Looking back, Yvonne says, there were signs something was wrong: one of the girls threw up not long after they got into the room and Yvonne developed a severe headache. But at the time, a long day of amusement rides and restaurant food seemed like logical reasons for feeling ill. Settling down to watch a movie, they all began to feel noticeably drowsy, so much so they weren’t able to stay awake to finish it.

A CO alarm in the hotel room would have alerted them to the fact they were not suffering from the after effects of a long day or bad food, they were being poisoned by the air in their room. CO detection in the hotel would have alerted the staff to the life-threatening situation that was quickly developing (due to a dislodged water heater ventilation pipe) and the need to immediately evacuate the building. But there were no alerts to anyone because there was no CO detection of any kind anywhere in the hotel.

The Boughters turned off the movie, crawled into bed, and fell deeper into the effects of the CO: drifting in and out of consciousness, suffering uncontrollable bouts of vomiting throughout the night and into the next morning.

Yvonne doesn’t have a clear memory of all that happened that night (CO poisoning causes confusion and hallucinations). She does remember being roused into consciousness at the sound of Patrick’s labored breathing and her daughter crying out for help. She managed to reach the phone and call 911 before losing consciousness again. An ambulance was dispatched.

Around the same time, in two rooms down the hall from the Boughters, another family was also unknowingly suffering the effects of CO poisoning, violently ill with nausea and vomiting. They had called for an ambulance suspecting they might be suffering from food poisoning. In total, three ambulances responded to the hotel to render aid to victims in three different rooms, but they mistakenly missed the Boughter’s room. The response focused only on the other victims who were subsequently transported to the hospital where they were misdiagnosed with food poisoning, treated, and released.

Meanwhile back at the hotel, the Boughters continued to lay helpless in their room, unconscious and still inhaling the CO that no one had yet identified. Four hours after her initial call, Yvonne came to and again called 911. Dispatchers quickly sent another ambulance to the hotel. But by the time they arrived, Patrick was dead along with 10-year-old Kelly. Yvonne and Morgan were rushed to the hospital where they were diagnosed with severe CO poisoning. The other victims were contacted and instructed to return to the hospital to be treated for CO poisoning as well.

Our hearts go out to Yvonne and Morgan, survivors of an “accident” that should have never happened; their lives forever changed by unimaginable loss, trauma, and injury that could have easily been prevented.

CO poisoning incidents in hotels are not rare. Since Patrick and Kelly’s deaths in 2006, at least 18 more people have died of CO poisoning in U.S. hotels – 5 of them children. Despite ongoing tragic outcomes such as these, CO detection is still not required in most hotels in the U.S.
Protect your family by carrying a CO alarm when you travel. If you hear it alerting to CO, immediately get outside to fresh air and call 911. Along with saving your family, your actions may save the lives of others as well.

For more information on CO poisoning in hotels and how to stay safe while traveling visit https://thejenkinsfoundation.com/hotel-co-incidents/

Remembering Jeffrey Williams and thinking of his mom, Jeannie ❤️ 6.8.2013

Always in our hearts…

Seven years ago today, 11-year-old Jeffrey and his mom, Jeannie, were poisoned by CO in a hotel room in Boone, NC…the same room where Daryl and Shirley Jenkins had died seven weeks earlier, on 4.16.2013. Jeffrey died. Jeannie survived but with permanent injury to her brain. You can read more about what happened here.

Remember to always carry a CO alarm when traveling, and if it alerts to CO, immediately get outside to fresh air and call 911.

Read more about the Jeffrey Lee Williams Foundation at www.jeffreysfoundation.org

Jeannie and Jeffrey Williams

VT hotel evacuates due to fumes

Quality Inn, Rutland, VT – “…and the portion of the building where the rooms were located measured at 300 ppm…the building had 64 rooms, most or all of which were occupied by multiple people…vulnerable population and also apparently some essential workers…” Source of CO listed as a gas powered power washer.

https://www.rutlandherald.com/news/local/hotel-evacuates-due-to-fumes/article_328aff49-e060-59d8-93ca-f877dc23c81c.html?utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&utm_campaign=user-share&fbclid=IwAR2GvzyGgIdv7R1LhCqH8bVP4afkZMgBmzFbc6KC9Rg48T_bTBdrCrA6Ucs

Remembering Daryl & Shirley Jenkins ❤️ 4.16.2013

Sharing this sweet photo of of the namesakes of this Foundation, Daryl and Shirley Jenkins, back when they were high school sweethearts in the 1950s. Seven years ago today they both lost their lives to carbon monoxide poisoning in a hotel room while they were on vacation. This year they would have celebrated their 80th birthdays and 60 years of marriage…just a few of many joys we’ve missed sharing with them.

Carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning is 100% preventable if you have an alarm to alert you to its presence. 30 years ago technology, remarkably, provided that for us. For a relatively small expense, you can safeguard your family by installing CO alarms in your home. We get regular reminders from our fire and life safety agencies to make sure our homes are safeguarded with these lifesaving devices, on every level and near all sleeping areas.

Unfortunately, we seldom hear about the lack of safeguards when we leave home…and the very real fact that there are no universal requirements for hotels and other businesses to take the same measures by installing CO detection systems to protect us when we visit and stay in their buildings. This means that not only are we inadvertently putting ourselves and our families at risk by not being aware (would anyone knowingly choose to sleep unprotected from a toxic gas in any hotel?), we are also not being warned to carry our own alarm when we travel.

Public health protection in this country might not be what you think it is – never has this been more collectively apparent than right now. You can be poisoned by CO in any building. Don’t be lulled into a false sense of security just because you’ve installed CO alarms in your home. Don’t take the safety of your indoor air for granted no matter where you are, especially in places where you sleep.

We might not currently have the public health protections we deserve, but we have access to factual information and the ability to share it to prompt change and to help protect each other until those changes are made.

Knowledge can save your life. Sharing it can save someone else’s life.

Visit our website to read more about Daryl and Shirley’s story and how to stay CO safe when traveling https://thejenkinsfoundation.com/hotel-co-incidents/

To read more about existing CO requirements in hotels and other public buildings, visit https://www.ncsl.org/…/carbon-monoxide-detectors-state-stat…)

Earthquake damage reports keep flowing in…Salt Lake Valley

“Building owners should be especially concerned about brick chimneys…Inspect the chimneys for loose bricks. If the chimney provides ventilation for a fireplace or appliances such as furnaces or water heaters, make sure it still vents…also encourage building owners to ensure they have a working carbon monoxide detector.”

https://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2020/03/23/aftershocks-spur-plea/?fbclid=IwAR0LVhV-QNCjivg7sJFMFvDhE-2HdF5gZYvWHquVcHkZk6syD5IJINxRXG4

Michigan hotel CO poisoning prompts federal action

“Last year, a Lakeville woman and her son were hospitalized after they were nearly killed by carbon monoxide they breathed in at a Michigan hotel. Seven months later, Leslie Lienemann is still recovering from the acute carbon monoxide poisoning she experienced, and she wants to make sure no one else goes through what she has.”

https://www.hometownsource.com/sun_thisweek/community/dakota_county/near-fatal-co-poisoning-prompts-action/article_31f0945e-653f-11ea-8b65-bf782a2298ad.html?utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&utm_campaign=user-share&fbclid=IwAR0tSUpd0FqpC4seH0MFrDgICH7AVPcNYJV0eMjN8K0zuKJ7UcnOT55RsNA

Coroner’s office releases death causes for victims of Alpine Motel fire in Las Vegas

“Four of the (six) victims died of acute carbon monoxide toxicity, the coroner’s office said.”

🔥Did you know…”CO poisoning is the major contributing cause of death in fire victims.” (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK430740/#!po=4.54545)

https://www.fox5vegas.com/news/crime/coroner-s-office-releases-death-causes-for-victims-of-alpine/article_8b44ec3c-58db-11ea-bf74-773ee5a4eaa1.html?utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&utm_campaign=user-share&fbclid=IwAR3W6KGEKVM17Nb26n68RdJ-lWaMR_PMqztw8qRX6ngUR5hhAudFCw3PvjU

Remembering Walt and Molly Weber ❤️ 2.10.1995

This is Walt and Molly Weber. On this weekend 25 years ago they headed off to a lodge in Mammoth, CA, for a weekend of fun and skiing. They arrived late in the evening and, looking forward to hitting the slopes early the next morning, requested a wake-up call and crawled into bed. Little did they know these would be the last moments their lives would ever be the same.

They were found unresponsive 36 hours later by hotel staff (because they had missed checkout), still in bed. Walt was pronounced dead by emergency responders, and Molly was barely alive. Both had been poisoned by carbon monoxide (CO) leaking undetected from a broken heater in the room. The hotel had no CO detection installed, so there had been no alert for them to evacuate and no alert to the hotel staff there was a life-threatening problem developing their building. Instead, business had carried on as usual as Walt and Molly lay dying, in desperate need of rescue for almost two full days.
Incredibly, Molly survived, but with such severe injury to her brain she was unable to swallow, speak or walk when she woke up from a coma nine days later. It took weeks for her to comprehend that Walt, the love of her life, was dead. Much of the damage to her brain was irreversible, impacting her personality and preventing her ability to ever live independently again.

Walt and Molly’s story is one among many similar “accidents” that continue to happen in U.S. hotels due to lack of proper CO safeguards, including the installation of CO detection systems, emergency procedures and staff training. Deaths and injuries due to CO are 100% preventable. We are working hard to bring public and industry awareness to this issue and the need for immediate change. You can help by sharing this information with your family and friends and encouraging them to carry their own CO alarm when they travel.

Thank you to Molly and her sister, Lyrysa Smith, for sharing Walt and Molly’s story. You can read more here https://www.timesunion.com/…/A-sister-lost-found-5721855.php and in Lyrysa’s book https://www.lyrysasmith.com/a-normal-life/

Utility malfunction causes carbon monoxide scare in Keene, NH

“The utility realized it was sending out the wrong mixture of gas to air to appliances such as boilers, clothes dryers, and stoves, with too much natural gas being sent out into the supply line. That type of mix could lead to carbon monoxide leaking into homes and businesses…”  Businesses affected included the Marriott Hotel on Railroad Street.

https://www.unionleader.com/news/safety/utility-malfunction-causes-carbon-monoxide-scare-in-keene/article_f427e91b-f973-5a26-983b-908cecffbf3e.html?utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&utm_campaign=user-share&fbclid=IwAR0CiOhgdaS6u9d_b0fElVVxF67gwlQG5RdZUUbMnlvvQ4Pzc-gu7bPHuRA

 

Hotels – A Hidden Source of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning

Forbes –  by Judy Stone, MD

A unique look at what it’s like to be poisoned by carbon monoxide in your hotel room. Thankfully these victims survived, however their experience highlights some of the many unaddressed questions of CO safety in hotels…namely, who is watching out for us when we check in?

https://www.forbes.com/sites/judystone/2020/01/09/hotelsa-hidden-source-of-carbon-monoxide-poisoning/?fbclid=IwAR2IzqlrLxjkXdtB_7l5B3rOiQvjXNoaal9ObXo0aoMUEuG7_D3FFVcjPAg#8141a2258cb8

 

Carbon Monoxide Poisonings in Hotels and Motels: The Problem Silently Continues

Just published in Preventive Medicine Reports…The Jenkins Foundation’s spreadsheet of hotel CO incidents helps add to 30 years (1989-2018) of published, publicly accessible data regarding CO poisoning in U.S. hotels. Thanks to leading CO researchers Dr. Neil Hampson, Dr. Lindell Weaver, and Kayla Deru, victims of these incidents now have a collective voice in the effort to bring attention to the to lack of universal requirements for CO detection in hotel buildings.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211335519301469?fbclid=IwAR1zKeLgbwNjYk4ZaVF-pCRYUWHKpppf0o-_QYscWp_b-3mYZwHY3KJlDoM

 

2nd evacuation in two weeks for Myrtle Beach hotel

Hampton Inn – Myrtle Beach SC

https://www.wbtw.com/news/broadway-at-the-beach-hotel-evacuated-again-after-carbon-monoxide-leak-reported/?fbclid=IwAR0NLcVKn8we4-f_JxRB06e8SuZg8s3L3jj-CxJw0HWhf48BXDbl4jyviNo

NFPA Handout (with links)

Carbon Monoxide Poisonings – Is a Silent Killer Lurking in Hotel Rooms?

NFPA Conference & Expo – June 2019

For more information about the Jenkins Foundation, please visit our website and Facebook page:

https://thejenkinsfoundation.com/

https://www.facebook.com/thejenkinsfoundation/

 

Spreadsheet – U.S. Hotel/Motel Carbon Monoxide Incidents 1967 – to date

https://thejenkinsfoundation.com/hotel-co-incidents/

 

Interactive map of spreadsheet data

https://www.insightrisk.com/resources/carbon-monoxide-hotels/

 

Carbon Monoxide Poisoning at Motels, Hotels, and Resorts (1989 – 2004)

Lindell K. Weaver, MD; Kayla Deru, BA

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17572307

 

Cherry-red skin not a reliable indicator of CO poisoning

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11563729

 https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS014067360579810X.pdf

  

Diffusion of Carbon Monoxide Through Gypsum Wallboard

Neil B. Hampson, MDTodd G. Courtney, BSJames R. Holm, MD

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1730499

http://neilhampson.com/carbon-monoxide.html

 

Myth busting in carbon monoxide poisoning

Neil B. Hampson, MD

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26632018

 

For more information on the cases featured in this presentation:

Daryl & Shirley Jenkins/Jeannie & Jeffrey Williams

2013 – Boone, NC

https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/special-reports/nc-medical-examiners/jeffrey-williams/article9093218.html

 

Bruce & Joan Plagman/Betty & Mary Bishop

1967 – Boston Heights, OH

https://www.ohio.com/article/20121112/NEWS/311129370

 

Walt & Molly Weber

1995 – Mammoth Lakes, CA

A Normal Life: A Sister’s Odyssey Through Brain Injury by Lyrysa Smith

http://www.lyrysasmith.com/

 

Boughter Family

2006 – Ocean City, MD

https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-2006-07-11-0607110198-story.html

 

Bryan Douglas-Watts

2017 – Niles, MI

https://abc7chicago.com/news/hotel-co-leak-kills-13-year-old-boy-attending-birthday-party/1832154/

 

David & Patricia Ivie

2017 – Perryton, TX

http://highplainsobserverperryton.com/son-wants-to-bring-more-awareness-to-carbon-monoxide-poisoning-at-hotels-p23044-267.htm

https://www.mankatofreepress.com/news/silent-killer-good-thunder-couple-calls-for-greater-carbon-monoxide/article_722da518-1788-11e8-9a45-ffed270f1628.html

 

Why Are Guests Still Dying from Hotel Gas Leaks?

https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/local/article196353719.html

 

 

 

 

6 years later…remembering Daryl and Shirley Jenkins ❤️ 4.16.2013

Six years ago today, Daryl and Shirley Jenkins lost their lives to CO poisoning in a hotel room while on vacation in Boone, NC. In memory of them and the thousands of other victims who have been injured and/or died in U.S. hotels of this very preventable cause, we shared a series of four posts on The Jenkins Foundation Facebook page…https://www.facebook.com/thejenkinsfoundation/

Read More >

1 dead, at least 11 poisoned by hotel CO leak in Niles, MI

“Hotel staff found the children lying unresponsive at an indoor pool deck and the breakfast area adjacent to the pool at 10 a.m. ET after noticing their figures through a window…The Fire Department also said it found one of the children in a first-floor room unconscious and not breathing…One hotel worker, along with two Berrien County officers and two Niles city police officers were also treated for exposure to the poisonous gas.”

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/1-dead-least-11-poisoned-michigan-hotel-carbon-monoxide-leak-n741586

Plastic used by workers caused CO to build up at Best Western

Best Western Allentown Inn & Suites – Allentown, PA

“No one realized the man was suffering from exposure to carbon monoxide — and that the poison gas, notorious for its deadly stealth, was already sickening other guests and workers…Philip D. Prechtel, 63, died in his room…One other guest, two employees, two police officers and three ambulance workers were taken to hospitals.